Building a True Cost Budget: A Comprehensive Guide

Nonprofits are often stuck in a funding gap: donors want to know their gifts create impact, but many are hesitant to cover the “overhead” that make impact possible. Additionally, leaders struggle to understand and explain the true cost of changing lives. The result? Programs that are underfunded, staff stretched too thin, and a mission that falls short of its potential.

The good news: True cost budgeting offers a clear and effective solution. It shows what it really takes to deliver impact—and gives leaders the tools to plan better and communicate effectively with donors.

Let’s get started

Understanding the full cost of delivering your nonprofit’s programs is essential for financial sustainability and effective mission delivery. True cost budgeting provides a clear picture of all expenses involved, enabling better planning, transparent communication with donors, and informed decision-making. Here’s an expanded guide covering 10 steps to build a true cost budget:

1. Define Your Programs

Identify Distinct Programs: Determine which activities constitute separate programs within your organization. This may align with how services are delivered or structured internally. Avoid overcomplicating; group similar activities under one program if they share goals, costs, and staff.

2. Establish Accounting Structure

Set Up Cost Centers: Configure your accounting system to track expenses by each program, management and general (administration), and fundraising. This organization facilitates accurate cost allocation and compliance with reporting requirements.

3. Identify Direct and Shared Costs

  • Direct Costs: Expenses exclusively tied to a specific cost center, such as program staff salaries, materials, and travel.

  • Shared Costs: Expenses that support multiple programs, like rent, utilities, and administrative salaries. These are also known as overhead or indirect costs.

4. Select Allocation Methods

Determine Allocation Bases: Choose reasonable methods to distribute shared costs across programs. Common bases include:

  • Full-Time Equivalent (FTE) or Staff Time: Allocating costs based on the proportion of staff time dedicated to each program.

  • Square Footage: Distributing costs like rent based on the space each program occupies.

  • Percentage of Total Direct Costs: Allocating shared costs in proportion to each program’s direct expenses.

5. Allocate Staff Salaries and Benefits

  • Assess Time Allocation: Determine how each staff member’s time is divided among programs and administrative duties. This can be done through timekeeping reports or estimates.

  • Distribute Costs Accordingly: Allocate salaries, benefits, and taxes to programs based on the time spent on each.

6. Assign Direct Expenses

Link Expenses to Programs: Directly assign costs that are clearly attributable to specific programs, ensuring accurate tracking and reporting.

7. Allocate Shared Costs

Apply Chosen Methods: Use your selected allocation bases to distribute shared costs across programs, administration, and fundraising. Ensure the methods are reasonable and justifiable.

8. Include Reserve Contributions

Plan for Sustainability: Incorporate contributions to reserves, aiming for a target such as 3-6 months of operating expenses, to ensure financial stability.

9. Compile the True Cost

Summarize All Costs: Combine direct costs, allocated shared costs, and reserve contributions to determine the total cost of delivering each program.

10. Review and Communicate

  • Analyze the Data: Ensure the allocations accurately reflect resource usage and make adjustments if necessary.

  • Share with Stakeholders: Communicate the true costs to donors, board members, and staff to foster transparency and informed decision-making.

By meticulously following these steps, your nonprofit can develop a comprehensive understanding of the true costs associated with delivering its programs, leading to more effective budgeting, fundraising, and mission fulfillment.