Book Notes: War Room: The Legacy of Bill Belichick and the Art of Building the Perfect Team

I like football. I like coaching. I like books. Guess what, I like books about football coaches. Legendary San Francisco 49ers and Stanford University coach, Bill Walsh's The Score Takes Care of Itself if my favorite.

I recently finished War Room: The Legacy of Bill Belichick and the Art of Building the Perfect Team. If you don't like football or books about football, but you're a leader of a team or organization, don't stop reading! I'll spare you the details but highlight some leadership wisdom from the book.

Why this book matters

Bill Belichick is arguably the greatest NFL coach of all time. What sets him apart is his long-standing success. While other coaches come and go, Belichick built a dynasty with the New England Patriots. This book dives into the operation behind that success.

Here are five of Belichick’s winning strategies that can help you become a better leader.

Develop a Clear Vision and System

“Do your job.” This simple phrase was more than a motivational slogan. It was a core Belichick philosophy that emphasized the importance of every person in the organization knowing and executing their specific role.

Belicheck was an extremely detailed-oriented coach. He defined the role of every person in the organization (player, coach, manager, management) with meticulous detail.

He went further by connecting each detail of a role to its broader purpose in the organization's vision. Knowing what to do is important. Knowing why it mattered is more important.

For leaders of growing nonprofits, developing a clear vision and system where each team member understands their role and how it ties into the organization’s larger mission is essential. When people not only know what to do but also why it matters, they feel a deeper connection to the organization’s goals, leading to more focused and effective collaboration.

Prioritize Fit Over Talent

Because Belichick had clear vision for what everyone needed to do to create a winning team, he was able to emphasize finding players not necessarily withe the 'most talent' but those who fit his system.

His most famous player, Tom Brady, was drafted in the last round of the draft. Brady wasn't the 'most talented' quarterback in the draft, but his competitive spirit, dedication, and attention to detail fit perfectly into the Patriots system.

Belichick also let go of star players who didn't fit in with the Patriots culture. When talented players, including Hall of Fame wide receiver, Randy Moss, refused to check their egos at the door, Belichick found ways to move them off the team in favor of players who would represent a team-first ethos.

Finally, Belichick drafted players who were undervalued by other teams but who possessed qualities aligned with the Patriots’ core values. Players like Julian Edelman and Wes Welker, for instance, weren’t the most physically dominant players but had a relentless work ethic, discipline, and team-oriented focus that made them ideal for Belichick’s system. These players became key contributors to the Patriots success.

For growing nonprofits, prioritizing fit over talent ensures that every team member aligns with the organization’s mission and values, creating a unified team. By choosing individuals who bring dedication, adaptability, and a commitment to the organization’s goals, leaders can build a culture of collaboration and purpose that drives long-term success—even if those individuals don’t have the highest credentials on paper.

Cultivate a Culture of Accountability

Belichick demanded accountability on all levels. He was always evaluating everyone: did you do your job?

Belichick could be hard on people. Even the best players could escape accountability. In post-game film review sessions, he called out errors from any player, no matter their status or role, and hold them to the same standard.

Belichick demanded the same from himself. In one instance in the book, the author described how Belichick acknowledged his own tactical mistakes in front of the team, reinforcing that everyone—including the head coach—has room to grow.

This level of transparency sends a powerful message to the entire team: everyone is responsible for their performance, and no one is above the system.

Mistakes are inevitable. But they are opportunities to learn and improve.

For leaders of growing nonprofits, this culture of accountability can be transformative. When everyone, from staff to leadership, is open to constructive feedback and shares responsibility for the organization’s success, it creates an environment where trust and resilience flourish. This culture of mutual accountability fosters a commitment to improvement, helping the organization adapt and grow even through challenges.

Focus on Fundamentals

Belichick’s focus on fundamentals is a huge part of what makes the Patriots so consistent. In War Room, Holley explains how Belichick has even the most experienced players practice core skills like tackling, footwork, and blocking—things they’ve done a thousand times.

But to Belichick, mastering the basics is what separates good teams from great ones. By drilling these essentials over and over, he builds a team that can rely on solid fundamentals when it counts, especially under pressure.

For organizations, this focus on core skills is a reminder that the basics really matter. Just like football players practice their form, team members benefit from just 'getting reps.' That is, practicing to regularly reinforcing their essential skills, whether it’s clear communication, fundraising ask of a major donor, or leading a great meeting.

Keeping everyone sharp on the basics doesn’t just boost performance—it creates a culture where everyone’s ready to handle whatever comes their way, knowing they’ve got the fundamentals locked down.

Stay Focused on Process over Outcomes

Belichick’s “process over outcome” approach is one of his most powerful coaching philosophies. He teaches his team that success isn’t just about the scoreboard or the big win—it’s about doing the little things right, every single time. Instead of letting players get distracted by the score or the pressure to win, he keeps them focused on each play, each assignment, and each responsibility. By building this discipline, Belichick helps his team stay steady and avoid making rushed, impulsive decisions when the game is on the line.

In War Room, Holley shows how Belichick’s emphasis on process helps players think clearly and perform at a high level, even in stressful situations. For example, when preparing for a game, Belichick doesn’t just strategize for the win; he gets his team ready for every scenario, down to the smallest details. Players are coached to trust in the routines they’ve practiced instead of letting emotions dictate their actions. This creates a results-oriented culture, but one where the real focus is on executing well and controlling what they can—knowing the outcomes will follow.

For organizations, this lesson is crucial. Staying focused on a solid process rather than just end results helps create a steady, disciplined team that doesn’t buckle under pressure. When everyone’s committed to doing their job well, regardless of immediate results, it builds resilience and a consistent level of performance. The right outcomes will come, but only when there’s a team-wide commitment to doing the right things, the right way, time after time.

Again, this post isn't about football. The leadership lessons from Bill Belichick are a masterclass in building resilient, high-performing teams.

By creating a clear vision, prioritizing fit over talent, fostering accountability, reinforcing fundamentals, and staying committed to process, Belichick has built a dynasty that leaders of growing nonprofits can learn from and apply to their own organizations.

Do you want a practical way to apply these lessons in your leadership?

My 7 Pillars of Growing Nonprofits model can help leaders put these principles into action, ensuring their teams are aligned, adaptable, and ready to grow sustainably.

If you're looking for ways to build a stronger organization, I think you’ll appreciate my weekly newsletter, Growing Nonprofits. Every week, I explore the insights nonprofit leaders need to navigate growth challenges and make a meaningful impact.

Subscribe to receive:

• 3 meaningful, actionable takeaways from the latest book I’m reading (like this one!);

• 2 practical ideas on strategy, operations, and management, and

• 1 reflection on the broader journey of growing as a leader.